Can the Russian S 400 shoot down a US B-2 Spirit Stealth Bomber in Syria?
Can the Russian S 400 shoot down a US B-2 Spirit Stealth Bomber in Syria?
B-2 Spirit, and F 35 LightningII |
B-2 Spirit Stealth Bomber and the S-400:
Let's not confuse remote theoretical possibilities
with practical feasibility, and also keep in mind the consequences of a
possible shootdown.
Under
normal circumstances, the radar cross-sections of the B-2 Spirit Stealth
Bomber and the F-22 Raptor are below that of a small bird (F 35 LightningII does not have all-around stealth, only frontal
stealth), At the altitudes where the B-2 Spirit fly, visualdetection
from the ground is not possible.
This
Stealth Bomber their radar cross-section for brief periods of
time when releasing their weapons, because the B-2 Spirit uses its
shielded Raytheon AN/APQ-181 radar only momentarily to identify a target just
before attacking.
The B-2Spirit has a highly advanced, classified electronic warfare system. but
that's too short to track or guide missiles. Besides, air-defense radars remain
off most of the time (otherwise, their life span would be unenviable) whereas
passive systems are inaccurate and way too easy to jam (say, just when the F-22
releases weapons).
S-400 |
There
is some mythology about S 400's ability to track US stealth planes using
the new radar Nebo-UM, This radar it is claimed that he can monitors the
airspace, detects various targets and determines their coordinates. The station
can detect and track both aerodynamic targets, including aircraft, helicopters
and cruise missiles, and ballistic missile warheads. The radar detects a
target, determines its coordinates and state affiliation and transmits
information to air defense crews or the command and control post. Besides, it
can take the bearings of jamming sources and determine their location. The
station detects targets at a range of 600 km and at an altitude of up to 80 km.
it
is claimed also the radar system Nebo-UM he can detect a hypersonic cruise
missile with a RCS of 0.9 square meters can be detected at 250 kilometers
flying at 10,000 meters of altitude or at 300 kilometers flying at 20,000
meters. A fighter aircraft with a radar cross section (RCS) of 2.5 square
meters at 65 kilometers flying at 500 meters of altitude, at 310 kilometers
flying at 10,000 meters or at 400 kilometers flying at 20,000 meters. And also
the Nebo-UM radar has been provided with advanced digital techniques to
suppress natural clutter and active jammers.
The Radar System Nebo-UM |
But
note that S-400 is based on trailers or mobile chassis, which limits the size,
emit/receive frequency, and the energy of the radar (you would do better with a
soccer-field size radar near a power station, or a much larger array like the
one built by the Russia near the Chernobyl nuclear power plant - but such a
stationary array is easier to target and sabotage). Russia
only has such networks on some parts of its vast territory, and certainly not
in Syria.
But
let’s assume for a second that a Russian S 400 system managed to detect
a US B-2 Spirit and locked a radar on it. This will be immediately
detected by the B-2 Spirit and probably by the AWACS or NATO E-3 plane
on duty. In response, the S 400 and the radar location will be targeted
by any number of US assets nearby that carry cruise missiles, AGM-129 ACM
or AGM-158 JASSM. The surface navy and submarines, the B-2 Spirit
itself, and any F-35 Lightning II on
patrol at the time (I can venture a guess that there will be a pair of B-2s,
and they will be accompanied by two F-22s and two F-35 LightningII at a certain distance, with F-22s being invisible to
other planes).
Just
sticking it to the US isn’t a good purpose, as you can expect to be stuck from
many sides in return. So, whoever goes for that, better have a good purpose.
Shooting
down a large US plane might bring harsh response and loss of valuable property.
So, before attempting to shoot down a B-2 Spirit, one needs to evaluate
their goals, the chances of success, the cost, as well as the consequences in
cases of success and failure.
To get close to a high-speed, high-altitude target
such as B-2 Spirit
before it goes out of range, a surface-to-air missile "S-400"
needs to pick up altitude very quickly (while the target is cruising
horizontally very quickly), which takes significant fuel, which takes
significant energy, which makes the missile heavier, which requires more energy
and fuel, and also limits the missile’s range and constrains maneuvers. Most
importantly, a missile accelerating to several Mach from ground level (through
relatively dense air) will be surrounded by hot plasma and can be easily
detected by radar and thermal imaging. So, the B-2Spirit will have at least (20s of
lead time, likely more), can deploy countermeasures and track the incoming
missile.
In
effect, whatever the US Military is trying to accomplish with the B-2Spirit, it is probably trying to accomplish in others ways too (The surface
navy, submarine-launched cruise missiles, The US short-range ballistic missile
system MGM-140 ATACMS, etc, etc).
The US short-range ballistic missile system MGM-140 ATACMS |
So, the
risks are high, the costs are high, (and bad PR for S 400 may undermine
future sales), the chances to hit a B-2 Spirit questionable, and even if
a B-2 Spirit is hit by an S 400 missile, Russia may lose the
entire S 400 encampment as well as some choice outpost - that might be
awkward (for example, if the Tartus wharf goes, the entire Russian story for
Naval presence in the Mediterranean). The chances for embarrassment are
significant.
On
the other hand, Russia should not be underestimated. The lesson to be learnt by
a silly observer is that, the F-117 Nighthawk, which is said to be stealthier
compared to the B-2 Spirit (0.001sq.m Vs 0.1sq.m, that's 100 times
stealthier for the F-117), was downed and another one severely damaged in 1999
by Yugoslvia using a 1960s era Soviet Isayev S-125 "Neva", and this
whatever the excuse the US can seek in order to save their face of
exceptionally advanced, and technologically unbeatable country.
No comments